In the Twin Cities, our roofs and gutters face year-round challenges — from piles of fall leaves to heavy spring rains and melting winter snow. Keeping your gutters clear isn’t just about appearance; it’s about preventing water damage, protecting your foundation, and avoiding costly repairs. But here’s the big question: should you invest in gutter guards or stick with seasonal gutter cleaning?

Let’s break down the pros, cons, and costs so you can make the best choice for your Minnesota home.

Why Gutters Matter in Minnesota

• Protect Against Water Damage – Gutters keep rain and snowmelt flowing away from your foundation, preventing cracks and basement leaks.
• Stop Ice Dams Before They Form – Clogged gutters trap water, which freezes, leading to damaging ice dams.
• Save on Repairs – Water intrusion repairs can cost thousands. Regular gutter maintenance is a fraction of that.

Option 1: Seasonal Gutter Cleaning

What it is: Clearing leaves, twigs, and debris from your gutters 2–3 times per year, either DIY or by hiring a pro.

Pros:
– Low upfront cost
– Flexible (you only pay when you clean)
– Keeps gutters fully visible for inspection (leaks, pests, loose fasteners)

Cons:
– Needs to be done multiple times per year in Minnesota
– Labor-intensive or recurring service cost
– Ladder work can be dangerous, especially in icy conditions

Option 2: Gutter Guards

What they are: Mesh, screen, or helmet-style covers that block most debris while allowing water to pass through.

Pros:
– Reduces frequency of cleanings (often down to once a year)
– Prevents most leaf and pine needle clogs
– Helps minimize ice dam formation by improving drainage
– Safer since you’re not climbing ladders as often

Cons:
– Higher upfront cost
– Still require occasional rinsing and checks
– Effectiveness varies depending on debris type and roof slope

Minneapolis Area Gutter Guard Providers You Can Trust

If you’re considering installing gutter guards, here are some top local companies we’ve seen homeowners trust:

• Gutter Helmet of Minnesota – Their “Designer Series” system comes with a bold promise: if your gutters ever clog, they’ll clean them for free. Great peace-of-mind for Twin Cities weather.
• LeafFilter (Minneapolis) – Known for high-quality micro-mesh guards and lifetime warranties, designed specifically for local rainfall, foliage, and freeze–thaw cycles.
• Sela Gutter Connection – A well-established, family-run Minneapolis provider offering Leaf-X systems and seamless installation, with decades of trusted service.
• Gutter Filter – Offers a fully enclosed stainless-steel micro-screen, built to last and backed by a strong lifetime guarantee—ideal for homeowners tired of frequent clean-outs.
• Call The Gutter Guys – Local pros with knowledge of multiple guard options (EZ Gutter Guard, Leaf Blaster Pro, etc.), and helpful comparative advice to match your needs and price range.

Cost Comparison: Cleaning vs. Guards

• Seasonal Cleaning in Twin Cities: $150–$300 per visit, 2–3 times a year.
• Gutter Guards Installed: $7–$15 per linear foot installed (average home: $1,500–$3,000).
• Break-Even Point: Guards often pay for themselves in 5–7 years, depending on your home’s tree cover and cleaning frequency.

Which Is Best for Twin Cities Homes?

• Surrounded by Trees? Gutter guards are usually worth it.
• Few Trees or Tight Budget? Seasonal cleaning is perfectly fine.
• Commercial or Multifamily? Gutter guards reduce ongoing maintenance costs.
• Hybrid Approach: Many homeowners install guards but still schedule an annual pro cleaning for peace of mind.

Expert Advice from Right Now Roofing & Restoration

At Right Now Roofing & Restoration, we’ve seen it all: overflowing gutters that ruined siding, hidden ice dams causing attic mold, and clogged drains leading to flooded basements. Our advice? Don’t wait until you see water damage. Proactive gutter care is the best way to protect your biggest investment.

Whether you prefer seasonal cleaning or want to explore gutter guards, our team can help you choose what’s right for your home and budget.

Conclusion

Both gutter guards and seasonal cleaning have clear benefits — the right choice depends on your property and goals. The important thing is doing something before clogged gutters cause damage.

Schedule your free gutter and roof inspection today with Right Now Roofing & Restoration and find out which option is best for your Twin Cities home.

Do gutter guards prevent ice dams?
Not entirely, but by keeping water flowing they reduce the conditions that lead to ice dams. Proper attic insulation and ventilation are still key.

How often should gutters be cleaned in Minnesota?
Typically 2–3 times per year: once in spring, once in late fall, and sometimes mid-summer if you have lots of trees.

Can I install gutter guards myself?
Some types are DIY-friendly, but professional installation ensures better fit, performance, and warranty coverage.

Are gutter guards worth the cost?
If you have heavy tree cover or want a “set it and forget it” solution, they can pay for themselves over time. If you have minimal debris, seasonal cleaning may be more cost-effective.

Maurice Campbell

Maurice Campbell brings over 20 years of extensive experience in the roofing and siding industry to his role as co-owner of Right Now Roofing. Maurice began his career in roofing installation, where his technical skills and problem-solving abilities set him apart. His career progressed into project management, where he successfully managed complex roofing and siding projects, ensuring they were completed on time and within budget.